What defines a “dangerous” sport. I do agree that some are more dangerous than others, but even the tamest of games have potential for disaster. I get very defensive when people try to attack Adventure Racing as an “unduly dangerous” sport.
I do admit that on the surface it sounds pretty loony. “I’ve got an idea, let’s not sleep for three days while covering hundreds of kilometres in the rough back country where it is questionable if foot has been tread there before while occasionally nodding off going 30km/h on a bike just after the 100m rappel into a freezing lake.”
The truth of the matter is that although the sport isn’t completely devoid of incident, the frequency and magnitude of the incidents are both relatively small. Relative to what you ask? Relative to many sports accepted as safe in our society. I do not claim that badminton, table tennis and chess are just as dangerous, but I do claim that as example, hockey, football, rugby, aussie-rules football, boxing, auto racing, marathoning, base jumping, etc. have just as much if not more risk associated with them.
My deepest regards go to the families of Nigel Aylott, Dominique Robert, René Arseneault and any others who have been claimed by the sport. Both Mr. Aylott and Mrs. Robert were taken by freak incident that could have and do happen to weekend adventurers. Mr. Arseneault was taken as a result of aggressive conditions existing in Eastern Canada’s Bay of Fundy that claims lives every year. I would never say that these incidents are in anyway acceptable, however if Adventure Racing were to not exist, incidents like this would still occur by regular weekend warriors doing their adventures. Considering that the sport has been happening since the mid-seventies, it has a pretty good running track record in comparison with many other sports.
I agree that steps need to be taken to reduce the risk of such incidences to an absolute minimum (which is happening with the advent of the
Canadian Adventure Racing Association), but the sport should not be abolished since many other successful sports have many deaths worldwide annually and are allowed to continue.
We need risk in our lives and Adventure Racing is a great way to safely get that fix.